The Defense Throws Punches, The Prosecution Fires Back

Day 30 of the Diddy trial brought the long-awaited defense closing argument, and Mark Agnifilo did not disappoint—unless, of course, you were expecting subtlety. The lead attorney framed the entire case as a dramatic overreach, calling it a “tale of two trials”—one based on real evidence and another stitched together by prosecutorial flair. He painted Diddy as a flawed but generous man, arguing that the allegations amounted to messy personal relationships, not a criminal enterprise. The jury, he insisted, should view the prosecution’s case as exaggerated, incomplete, and ultimately hollow.

Agnifilo didn’t shy away from the domestic violence accusations—in fact, he leaned into them. “We own the domestic violence,” he said, asserting that the defense never tried to discredit Cassie or Jane’s accounts of being hit or kicked. But, he argued, those incidents belonged in state court, not the federal arena of racketeering. He doubled down on portraying Combs as a powerful man targeted for money, pointing out that lawsuits from ex-partners preceded the criminal case. The courtroom got an earful about Astroglide, baby oil, and freak-off parties, with Agnifilo mocking the feds’ dramatic raids that yielded… personal lubricants and five Valium pills.

But when the prosecution fired back, Maureen Comey zeroed in on the legal meat. She called out Combs for knowingly flying escorts across state lines, then handing them cash after sex—a direct hit under federal trafficking laws. Text messages revealed Diddy asking escorts if they were cops, undermining the defense’s claim that the money was for “time,” not sex. Comey didn’t just reject the freak-off tapes as consensual kink; she reminded the jury that blackmail, coercion, and manipulation loomed large behind the curated sex performances. The courtroom antics may have been colorful, but her argument was surgical: this wasn’t about Diddy’s brand—it was about the law.

With both sides rested, the jury is set to receive the case on Monday. Whether the verdict comes fast or drags out, it’s clear the courtroom theater is winding down. Pugs Moran has covered every single day of this bizarre legal saga, and now it’s almost out of his hands. The only thing left? A decision that could reshape the legacy of one of hip-hop’s most polarizing figures.

Podcast (diddy): Play in new window | Download (Duration: 59:34 — 40.9MB)

Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | RSS